It’s All About the Tilt: Seasons Misconceptions Debunked

In the winter, when the days get shorter and the weather gets increasingly colder, it can seem like the Sun has forsaken us. I mean, after all, that’s when we are farthest from it—both physically and emotionally—right? Well, not exactly. While it might make sense to think that colder days equals farther distance from the Sun, it’s really not quite so simple. 

Children enjoying a snow dayWhat makes the winter so cold? Image: Creatas Images/Creatas/Thinkstock

The first component that complicates the matter is the Earth’s tilt itself. In Earth’s orbit around the Sun (which is slightly elliptical, not round) the planet is tilted on its axis at a degree of 23.5. This tilt means that the southern hemisphere and the northern hemisphere receive differing intensity of light in different seasons. This is why countries like Australia are celebrating cooler weather when weather in the northern hemisphere (like here in Washington, DC) is just starting to warm up. 

The second component that complicates winter weather is that Earth’s orbit around the Sun is slightly elliptical. This ellipse actually does allow for the Earth to be farther and closer to the Sun at different times of the year. However, in the northern hemisphere the Earth is closest to the Sun in the winter not the summer! This definitely sounds counterintuitive. On the one hand, this makes sense for the southern hemisphere. When the Earth is closest to the Sun it’s their summer. But how can we reconcile this confusion for the northern hemisphere? The answer lies in the 23.5 degree tilt and in light dispersion. 

Elliptical Cherry Cake

While a little exaggerated, the orbit of the Earth is a similarly shaped ellipse Image: Eising/Photodisc/Thinkstock


While Earth might not be farthest from the Sun during winter in the northern hemisphere, it is titled away. The southern hemisphere is pointed toward the Sun during this period; therefore, it receives the most direct rays of sunlight. Because the sunlight is so direct, it means that the energy hitting the southern hemisphere is strong. In contrast, the light hitting the northern hemisphere is dispersed and carries less energy. This tilt is also behind the “long” and “short” days in winter and summer. Depending on how direct the light is, the perceived length of days will change. 

One thing that can be so confusing about how seasons work is that there are so many moving parts to consider. Not only is the Earth orbiting the Sun, but it’s titled on an axis and also rotates around that axis—there’s a lot going on! Multi-facetted problems are the bread and butter of scientists, and they’ve developed some handy tricks to tackle them. Just like we did, scientists take apart complicated problems one piece at a time to understand a simpler part first before adding others. Just like a galactic-sized jigsaw puzzle! 

Learn more about the Sun, Earth, & the seasons! Watch Good Thinking!: ‘Tis the Season for a Reason 


Related Tags

About the Author

Sarah Wells
Digital Media Intern

Sarah Wells is a rising senior at Clark University and hails from Montpelier, Vermont. She is majoring in English with a double minor in physics and computer science.